I was quite busy these few months, didn't finish the company result analysis. I guess it is still alright, since the economy would only get worse, not getting better. So be it, what have been stuck is already stuck.
The recent news on Sino Env and Celestial just highlight to us again, the corporate governance issue of SGX listed China company. I think investors have doubts on the China company partly because we didn't really see the real business and we didn't really know how they do their business.
Sino Env went down because of the Chairman problem which could potential create a share over hang. Time is bad, if you are over leverage personally, it is a risk. Celestial wise, if I read correctly, is the convertible bond come calling. Actually I never expect them would be in this stage. Since the company is government supported entity, I guess it should run "correctly". But never say never. Figures I don't have. I just hope it can pull through the refinancing.
What has been taught in tex book is correct.
1. When you use debt, you enhance the shareholder return, but you also increase the risk
2. Small cap is more volatile, since there is limited resource available to them
Don't put all your money in small cap only. A certain level of diversification is needed, no matter how good the company is.
Sunday, 29 March 2009
Sunday, 1 March 2009
Hongguo FY08 financial result review
Hongguo just release the FY08 financial result. Let's look at whether the consumer spending is slowing down and what are the challenges ahead.
All amount in RMB ,000
Revenue + 19.6%
Cost of sales +21.9%
Selling and distribution expense +35.6%
Loss in joint venture +595% (6,247)
Profit of the year -3.39%
Cash and equivalent 115,376
FD 24,793
Inventories 343,805 (quite a lot)
Amount repayable in a year 65,801 (cash on hand should be able to service this)
Profit before income tax 126,099 (Cashflow quite flat)
Operating cashflow before working capital 156,575
Net cash from operating activities 33,589 (less than last FY)
Cash after adjust investing and financing 115,376
EPS 26.82 RMB cts (a drop compare to last year 27.76)
The revenue continue to grow, as the group open more store. However, the cost is running ahead of the sales. Gross profit margin drop from 40.6% to 39.4%, reverse the past year trend. The reality bites now, as consumer cut back spending, and more promotion activities is being carried out. If not the JV loss, the group might post slight profit growth. Quarter 4 figure got hit after more tax provision is provided. Cashflow wise, the group is generating enough cash for the debt repayment, this should not be a cause of concern.
As highlighted in the financial statement, China retail sector suffered as a result of financial crisis. The group would continue the outlet expansion to drive growth. No dividend is being declared. This seems to be a common practice now among small cap, since they want to conserve the cash for uncertainties ahead.
The result has broken the previous multi year growth trend. The group is not doing too bad, consider the current economy climate, they only suffered a small reduction in profit. I think the retail segment is still quite resilient. But prepare for another year of negative growth. If the EPS decline by 10% for FY09, it would be 24 RMB cts (5.4 SGD cts). At last done price of 0.16, the stock is selling at PE 2.96 which is really amazing.
However, don't forget, the earning now is uncertain. So, the conventional valuation technique like PE is not really working in this kind of environment. It also shows sign of time, when in bear market, cheap would go cheaper. Keep a close watch on it, whether earning would deteriorate more?
The China stimuli package should drive up the demand in coming year. Let's wait and see.
All amount in RMB ,000
Revenue + 19.6%
Cost of sales +21.9%
Selling and distribution expense +35.6%
Loss in joint venture +595% (6,247)
Profit of the year -3.39%
Cash and equivalent 115,376
FD 24,793
Inventories 343,805 (quite a lot)
Amount repayable in a year 65,801 (cash on hand should be able to service this)
Profit before income tax 126,099 (Cashflow quite flat)
Operating cashflow before working capital 156,575
Net cash from operating activities 33,589 (less than last FY)
Cash after adjust investing and financing 115,376
EPS 26.82 RMB cts (a drop compare to last year 27.76)
The revenue continue to grow, as the group open more store. However, the cost is running ahead of the sales. Gross profit margin drop from 40.6% to 39.4%, reverse the past year trend. The reality bites now, as consumer cut back spending, and more promotion activities is being carried out. If not the JV loss, the group might post slight profit growth. Quarter 4 figure got hit after more tax provision is provided. Cashflow wise, the group is generating enough cash for the debt repayment, this should not be a cause of concern.
As highlighted in the financial statement, China retail sector suffered as a result of financial crisis. The group would continue the outlet expansion to drive growth. No dividend is being declared. This seems to be a common practice now among small cap, since they want to conserve the cash for uncertainties ahead.
The result has broken the previous multi year growth trend. The group is not doing too bad, consider the current economy climate, they only suffered a small reduction in profit. I think the retail segment is still quite resilient. But prepare for another year of negative growth. If the EPS decline by 10% for FY09, it would be 24 RMB cts (5.4 SGD cts). At last done price of 0.16, the stock is selling at PE 2.96 which is really amazing.
However, don't forget, the earning now is uncertain. So, the conventional valuation technique like PE is not really working in this kind of environment. It also shows sign of time, when in bear market, cheap would go cheaper. Keep a close watch on it, whether earning would deteriorate more?
The China stimuli package should drive up the demand in coming year. Let's wait and see.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
